"I believe that it's difficult to kill an idea..."
- steamboat28
-
Topic Author
- Offline
- Banned
-
- Si vis pacem, para bellum.
Neil Gaiman wrote: I believe that it is difficult to kill an idea, because ideas are invisible and contagious, and they move fast.
I believe that you can set your own ideas against ideas you dislike. That you should be free to argue, explain, clarify, debate, offend, insult, rage, mock, sing, dramatise and deny.
I do not believe that burning, murdering, exploding people, smashing their heads with rocks (to let the bad ideas out), drowning them or even defeating them will work to contain ideas you do not like. Ideas spring up where you do not expect them, like weeds, and are as difficult to control.
I believe that repressing ideas spreads ideas.
I believe that people and books and newspapers are containers for ideas, but that burning the people will be as unsuccessful as firebombing the newspaper archives. It is already too late. It is always too late. The ideas are out, hiding behind people’s eyes, waiting in their thoughts. They can be whispered. They can be written on walls in the dead of night. They can be drawn.
I believe that ideas do not have to be right to exist.
I believe you have every right to be perfectly certain that images of god or prophet or man are sacred and undefilable, just as I have the right to be certain of the sacredness of speech, of the sanctity of the right to mock, comment, to argue and to utter.
I believe I have the right to think and say the wrong things. I believe your remedy for that should be to argue with me or to ignore me, and that I should have the same remedy for the wrong things that you think.
I believe that you have the absolute right to think things that I find offensive, stupid, preposterous or dangerous, and that you have the right to speak, write, or distribute these things, and that I do not have the right to kill you, maim you, hurt you, or take away your liberty or property because I find your ideas threatening or insulting or downright disgusting. You probably think my ideas are pretty vile, too.
I believe that in the battle between guns and ideas, ideas will, eventually, win.
Because the ideas are invisible, and they linger, and, sometimes, they are even true.
Eppur si muove: and yet it moves.
A.Div
IP | Apprentice | Seminary | Degree
AMA | Vlog | Meditation
Please Log in to join the conversation.
It all starts with knowledge. Knowledge is the absence of understanding and the awareness of our own ignorance. Because we are aware, we are pushed to eliminate this ignorance and by doing so we find knowledge. Everyone on this earth has the ability to find knowledege and understanding. Some may not have the recources, butthe ability is there. Speaking more on topic of philosophical understanding, because everyone has the ability to think there are essentially millions upon millions of ideas to be had. And Ideas, they are made up of specific pieces to a puzzle. The human mind, can put these pieces together and they form what we call an idea. Because our minds are always working, even on the subconscious layer, ideas are formed every moment of our life. They may not be good ideas, in fact I think most of them are not, but they are ideas nonetheless. It is because of that reason, because our minds are always putting these pieces together that there are ideas that pop up all over different cultures despite whatever barrier is in the way, be it language or culture or even time. These specific ideas of self and love and religion and belief and faith, all pop up because the pieces that make up these ideas are all the same, they are all common to every one of us and our mind construct them easily.
Its because of this, because of our subconscious mind always thinking, always piecing together ideas even as we sleep that we can wake with new ideas, or we have eukreka moments. Artists do it, Polititians do it, the great thinkers did it...More specifically It is difficult to kill an idea because Ideas cannot die, because Ideas are intrinsic to human nature, because Ideas all come from a common place that every single human being that is, was, or ever will be on this planet, can access. You can beat it out of a generation, you can burn it out of the books we write, you can even try to shape the minds of the very people who think them. BUT, they will always come back, every time, because Ideas are part of human nature and they are bart of the backbone that makes us what we are.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
wooow, that got really wierd....sorry..I didnt mean for all that to pop out of my brain x{
Please Log in to join the conversation.
And I have to say, I adore Neil Gaiman, and his wife Amanda F^&%&@G Palmer. Great people, and I've learned a lot from the work of both.
We've seen this cycle appear throughout history: an idea comes along that people become attached to, the established order kills all of those people, the idea survives either underground or - miraculously - reappears several generations later on its own, or in another part of the world. I think it speaks to the sameness of all humans at the core level, where despite societal influence, certain ideas exist as an apparently biological fact. We think a certain way because of how our genetics are wired, and so certain thoughts will constantly reform themselves.
On the specific topic I thin Neil was talking about - censorship - this is a really important point. And I especially love that he made sure to include that bit about humor, and being able to mock ideas. We've had plenty of attacks against humorists over the years who made fun of this holy thing, or that sacred thing - which tells me that the humor they use is infinitely more powerful than the ideas held by their attackers. In other words I think that ideas are powerful because they're beyond the ability of human beings to completely control, and the more control we try to exert to implement only the "right thoughts", the more we're actually devaluing those ways of thinking we hold most dear; we end up undermining our own ideas the second we say that they are the only ideas worth having. Again, that's why I appreciate humor and comedians so much - beyond just being able to make me laugh. Their entire goal in life is to poke fun at the status quo, the sacred - everything existing from solidified ideas.
But yeah, I'd love to see a day when war exists only as ideas, because everyone has finally realized that guns don't do any damn good.
We are all the sum of our tears. Too little and the ground is not fertile, and nothing can grow there. Too much, the best of us is washed away. -- J. Michael Straczynski, Babylon 5
Please Log in to join the conversation.
“The unreal is more powerful than the real, because nothing is as perfect as you can imagine it. Because its only intangible ideas, concepts, beliefs, fantasies that last. Stone crumbles. Wood rots. People, well, they die. But things as fragile as a thought, a dream, a legend, they can go on and on.” -Chuck Palahniuk
Please Log in to join the conversation.

We are all the sum of our tears. Too little and the ground is not fertile, and nothing can grow there. Too much, the best of us is washed away. -- J. Michael Straczynski, Babylon 5
Please Log in to join the conversation.