- Posts: 913
Why does it matter if Tim Farron thinks being gay is a sin?
Sue Perkins and David Walliams were among the celebrities who criticised Tim Farron for failing to answer the question.
He finally answered the question on Wednesday afternoon when asked in Parliament if being gay was a sin. He said "no I do not [think that]".
On Tuesday night, Channel 4's Cathy Newman asked the Liberal Democrats leader about his views on LGBT rights and gay people.
She asked: “A while back I asked you if you thought that homosexuality was a sin and you struggled to answer.
“Now you’ve had a while to consider that question, what is the answer?”
He replied: “I don’t think I struggled to answer it at all, Cathy. I think I’m not in the position to make theological announcements over the next six weeks.
“I’m not going to spend my time talking theology or making pronouncements.”
She reminded the Lib Dem leader that in 2015 she had asked him three times if homosexuality was a sin “and you said ‘we’re all sinners’. Is that still the answer?”
Farron replied: “As a Liberal, I’m passionate about equality, about equal marriage and about equal rights for LGBT people, for fighting for LGBT rights, not just in this country but overseas.
“Just because I’m Christian, it would be a bit boring for everybody to spend the next weeks asking me to make theological announcements that I’m not going to make.”
Shadow Chancellor John McDonnell said on Good Morning Britain that it is "appalling" if Tim Farron believes homosexuality is a sin urged him to clarify his position.
Comedian David Walliams tweeted: "Mr @timfarron you are definitely a sinner for your continued intolerance & prejudice. Please try and join the rest of us in the year 2017."
Bake Off's Sue Perkins said: "Tim Farron on C4 news failing to clarify his views on the gay community. 'We're all sinners'. It's 2017."
David Baddiel wrote: "Problem with people saying it's Tim Farron who's talking the most sense is: he's a fundamentalist Christian homophobe".
Writer Owen Jones said: "This is an absolute disgrace. But hey, I'm just some sinning gay, what would I know."
Tim Farron has said his abstention on the same-sex marriage bill does not mean he doesn't support it.
He, along with nine other Lib Dem MPs, abstained at the third reading of the same-sex marriage bill, despite previously voting for the legislation.
I was curious to know what people here thought, particularly those among us that are members of the LGBT Community?
Now he has eventually, given in to peer pressure and said that he does NOT think that being gay is a sin. But even if he'd thought it was, why should that matter?
We don't live in a Orwellian society, we don't have Thought Police that control what we think. We're entitled to have our own opinions, even if other people disagree with them. He is perfectly OK to think that being gay is a sin.
We also have free speech in this country, so not only is he allowed to think that being gay is a sin, he is also allowed to say that.
But he hasn't said that. He simply refused to comment on a theological topic, that he did not deem himself qualified enough to comment on. And because of that, he's branded an 'absolute disgrace', a 'bigot', and a 'homophobe'. And that gets me onto my main point.
What has he done that's bigoted? What has he done that's homophobic?
He hasn't attacked anyone, either verbally or physically. He hasn't harassed or caused distress to anyone. He hasn't infringed upon anyone rights.
For me, this line is key - “As a liberal, I’m passionate about equality, and equal marriage, about equal rights for LGBT people, for fighting not just for LGBT rights in this country, but overseas.”
So even if he did think it was a sin, he's taken an Evelyn Beatrice Hall stance of 'I do not agree with what you have to say, but I'll defend to the death your right to say it' attitude.
I guess my real question is why were celebrities, politicians, the media, and members of the public so appalled by what he said?
- Knight Senan'The only contest any of us should be engaged in is with ourselves, to be better than yesterday'
Please Log in to join the conversation.
In the end, his views shouldn't matter, as long as he does his job and doesn't allow faith to get in the way of his duty.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
Anyway. Some people believe it's a sin because it's their religion. Some people believe it's not a sin, and some people (Like the gay church of gayness?) believe it's god's first commandment.
Who would have thought there are people in the english-speaking world who not only call themselves liberals, but practice actual liberalism as well!So even if he did think it was a sin, he's taken an Evelyn Beatrice Hall stance of 'I do not agree with what you have to say, but I'll defend to the death your right to say it' attitude.
Convictions are more dangerous foes of truth than lies.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
JLSpinner wrote: The only influence religion should have on government is through the guidance of our morals.
Nope ..common sense and reason will do ....not that i dont like the Ten Commandments but i think the neighbours cow should make up her own mind by now

Please Log in to join the conversation.
Calan wrote: Very strong of you to allow someone to have an opinion even though you dont agree with it.
Does that require strength? or just indifference?
- Knight Senan'The only contest any of us should be engaged in is with ourselves, to be better than yesterday'
Please Log in to join the conversation.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
Please Log in to join the conversation.
Knight of the Order
Training Master: Jestor
Apprentices: Lama Su, Leah
Just a pop culture Jedi doing what I can
Please Log in to join the conversation.