Joseph Campbell is awful

More
5 years 7 months ago #320227 by rugadd
Replied by rugadd on topic Joseph Campbell is awful
Joseph Campbell is like anything else I read or listen too or watch. I take the things that are useful and discard the rest.

Please Log in to join the conversation.

  • Visitor
5 years 7 months ago #320229 by
Replied by on topic Joseph Campbell is awful

PaschalVehicle wrote: Trisskar: I don't disagree. The Power of Myth as a book is, indeed, just a transcript of an interview; and interviews are frequently not consistent, coherent, or enlightening by their very nature. It is frustrating however to have *required reading* for a program be, as I said and continue to emphasise, inconsistent at best and incoherent at worst. Perhaps I'm just reliving my own personal hell of Catcher in the Rye in high school. As for my priorities, Point A is the IP and Point B is admission into the Seminary, for a variety of reasons that have a great deal to do with my own personal idiosyncrasies, and that is certainly a goal for which I will tolerate fields and valleys of flowers. So dislike Campbell or not I'll still keep reading him and journaling.


Completely agree. I feel the temple should only focus on the Hero's Journey and it's incorporation towards the Jedi Path....the rest is just "Stuff & Nonsense" as Alan Watt's likes to say :-p

Please Log in to join the conversation.

  • Visitor
5 years 7 months ago #320230 by
Replied by on topic Joseph Campbell is awful

Vusuki wrote: So can you give some clear examples where a myth or story doesn't fit Campbell's idea of the Hero's Journey? I'm very interested in testing if it is possible to use the theory on any myth or whether I have to accord only a specific fragment of the model to the myth you give...


I don't believe all myths tell part of a whole story. There are many myth paradigms and Campbell's is only one form. He does conveniently ignore anything that does not fit his narrative. The Heroine for example. He considers the female roles in myth as a prize for the hero. According to Campbell there is no such thing as Heroine and females cannot have their own story without being intertwined with his version of "Hero". There are several other versions as well, including the anti hero story and the Homeric hero story, none of which follow the cycle that Campbell describes.

Please Log in to join the conversation.

  • Visitor
5 years 7 months ago - 5 years 7 months ago #320231 by
Replied by on topic Joseph Campbell is awful

Kyrin Wyldstar wrote: The Heroine for example. He considers the female roles in myth as a prize for the hero.


This is understandable and ligitimate. Back in the day and in most myths that is the role of a female. It is rare upon rare to have a female hero, it is only just recently that female hero's are so pushed for popularity these days. And the hero's journey monomyth as it is now is easily used and followed by our female heros.

There are several other versions as well, including the anti hero story


Has nothing to do with being a Jedi or a hero of virtue.... sooooo....not relevant...therefor no reason to mention it

and the Homeric hero story, none of which follow the cycle that Campbell describes.


seems to follow the heros journey just fine from my reading
Last edit: 5 years 7 months ago by .

Please Log in to join the conversation.

  • Visitor
5 years 7 months ago #320232 by
Replied by on topic Joseph Campbell is awful
First, the interviews and even The Power of Myth are more Cliff Note versions of Hero With a Thousand Faces. Just like any other academic, if we're going to judge the work, we have to judge it in its entirety. There are certainly big leaps taken by Campbell and he does try to shoehorn certain myths into his model, but we also have to consider the time during which his research was conducted and resources he had available to him. At the time he was doing it, he was one of the very few who had attempted to find similarity between a vast number of myths worldwide from various cultures. And he didn't have the benefit of the internet, or even computers for that matter. And most ancient mythology did feature male heroes. And there are translation issues. And, and, and...

When I consider his work in this light, I see it laying a foundation that we can use to further his study of mythology and perhaps expand upon it. Or we may eventually demonstrate that the Hero's Journey is inherently flawed. What I have been unable to deny is that his model does fit a lot of modern mythology including those featuring female heroes. Disney has especially embraced this, as far back ad Belle in Beauty and the Beast and the recent backstory of Maleficent. We see it in The Matrix. It shows up in the Hobbit and Lord of the Rings. Harry Potter and The Karate Kid follow the script pretty closely. It doesn't need to be dismissed offhand just because it has Campbell's name on it.

The reason I see value in including it in the IP is that we call ourselves Jedi and look to the fictional characters and the philosophy/mythology that influenced their creation. George Lucas has specifically mentioned numerous times that the story arc of Luke Skywalker is definitely influenced by the Hero's Journey model. He admits to borrowing from existing mythology from multiple cultures to create his Star Wars universe. To explore the theological and mythological influences of Star Wars without including Campbell would be like studying Aristotle while ignoring Plato and Socrates. We don't have to agree with Campbell, but we should not deny his role in influencing modern mythology, especially the cinema.

Please Log in to join the conversation.

  • Visitor
5 years 7 months ago #320235 by
Replied by on topic Joseph Campbell is awful

Trisskar wrote: This is understandable and ligitimate. Back in the day and in most myths that is the role of a female. It is rare upon rare to have a female hero, it is only just recently that female hero's are so pushed for popularity these days. And the hero's journey monomyth as it is now is easily used and followed by our female heros.


Actually there are a myriad of ancient heroine and strong female lead character myths. In fact it was the norm before Patriarchal warrior clans destroyed much of the ancient stories and practices by replacing them or modifying them with male figures. However many survived. There are tons of ancient heroine stories of the Goddesses like Artemis, Tiamat, Hel, Bastet, White Buffalo Calf Woman, Freya. Also there were the Amazons, Lilith, Eve, Atalanta, Hua Mulan, The Valkyrie - even real life figures like Joan of Arc of which legend has formed around. The list goes on and many of these legendary heroines have been downplayed over the centuries because of emphasis on male counterparts.


Trisskar wrote: Has nothing to do with being a Jedi or a hero of virtue.... sooooo....not relevant...therefor no reason to mention it


I never said it did and this is not a discussion on Jediism but a discussion on the heroes journey so I do find it relevant.

Trisskar wrote: seems to follow the heros journey just fine from my reading


Then your reading it wrong. ;)

Please Log in to join the conversation.