- Posts: 881
Can you have a relationship with someone and still be a jedi
4 years 1 week ago #343804
by
Replied by on topic Can you have a relationship with someone and still be a jedi
Dont Jedi avoid relationships because they cause conflicts?
Please Log in to join the conversation.
4 years 1 week ago #343805
by Kohadre
In fiction, Jedi avoided romantic relationships because of their tendencies to form attachment. Ironically, this is what lead to their eventual downfall and annihilation.
In practical application within the temple community, many Jedi here are in romantic relationships; with a significant number even being married or otherwise in domestic partnerships.
I'd ask as well, is it worth being a Jedi if such a key part of life is forbidden; or otherwise shunned?
Replied by Kohadre on topic Can you have a relationship with someone and still be a jedi
Fyxe wrote: Dont Jedi avoid relationships because they cause conflicts?
In fiction, Jedi avoided romantic relationships because of their tendencies to form attachment. Ironically, this is what lead to their eventual downfall and annihilation.
In practical application within the temple community, many Jedi here are in romantic relationships; with a significant number even being married or otherwise in domestic partnerships.
I'd ask as well, is it worth being a Jedi if such a key part of life is forbidden; or otherwise shunned?
The following user(s) said Thank You: Kobos
Please Log in to join the conversation.
4 years 1 week ago #343808
by Rex
formatted for emphasis
Replied by Rex on topic Can you have a relationship with someone and still be a jedi
Kohadre wrote:
Fyxe wrote: Dont Jedi avoid relationships because they cause conflicts?
In fiction ...
formatted for emphasis
The following user(s) said Thank You: Kohadre
Please Log in to join the conversation.
4 years 1 week ago #343810
by JamesSand
Replied by JamesSand on topic Can you have a relationship with someone and still be a jedi
I don't think it quite prudent to so emphasise the idea of relationships only being a source of conflict within fictional settings.
Anyone who has sworn to do a duty, is very likely to, at some point or another along the line, find a conflict between their desires, or the needs of their "relationships" vs the demands of their duty.
Most will seek to balance it as best they can, often not without significant cost....
Now whether it affects Jediism as a daily practice, perhaps not so much - but it is hard to have two masters, and many families don't appreciate playing second fiddle to a higher purpose....
Anyone who has sworn to do a duty, is very likely to, at some point or another along the line, find a conflict between their desires, or the needs of their "relationships" vs the demands of their duty.
Most will seek to balance it as best they can, often not without significant cost....
Now whether it affects Jediism as a daily practice, perhaps not so much - but it is hard to have two masters, and many families don't appreciate playing second fiddle to a higher purpose....
The following user(s) said Thank You: Kobos
Please Log in to join the conversation.
4 years 1 week ago #343812
by
Replied by on topic Can you have a relationship with someone and still be a jedi
Well no, I meant to say like real life though, I thought being a Jedi meant acting like the jedi in the movies?
Please Log in to join the conversation.
4 years 1 week ago #343813
by Rex
Replied by Rex on topic Can you have a relationship with someone and still be a jedi
The question was "don't Jedi avoid relationships because they cause conflicts?"
The answer is, look at the FAQ or Doctrine. This isn't just a bunch of people LARPing as characters from movies.
Saying you should have common sense in choosing your priorities (including relationships) should go without needing to be said
The answer is, look at the FAQ or Doctrine. This isn't just a bunch of people LARPing as characters from movies.
Saying you should have common sense in choosing your priorities (including relationships) should go without needing to be said
Please Log in to join the conversation.