So, why are people so focused on a moral right....

Moderators: Desolous, Reliah

So, why are people so focused on a moral right.... 20 Feb 2012 13:09 #50980

There is a socially acceptable status quo in the world that tells people that they need to follow a code that is "acceptable to the masses". No one is the same as the person next to them, so why are people forced to follow the morals and morays of the general public, even if the majority of the public does not believe in them?

Re: So, why are people so focused on a moral right.... 20 Feb 2012 14:30 #51016

  • Adder
  • Adder's Avatar
  • Knight
  • ID: 7778
There's the ethic of reciprocity, the 'Golden Rule' that you do not treat others how you would not want to be treated yourself, and also to treat others how you want to be treated. That's a good starting point for considering a universal standard of morality.... but even that seems to make a bad assumption that others have comparible health, happiness and capabilities as yourself - and ignores the important point that we do not know what other people might be going through. So if morality means proper behavior, I'd be more inclined to have a more regimented approach based on maximum compassion while not creating vulnerabilities in your own self.

Re: So, why are people so focused on a moral right.... 20 Feb 2012 14:46 #51026

What is right and what is wrong, that's the question!

I agree with the phrase "do unto others as you would have them do to you" but as Adder points out this only works when we consider the needs of each individual.

Generally I think that a person should be free to do as they wish as long as it does not harm anyone else in any way and in some way they contribute to the well-being of the society they live in if they are able.

The Force will be with you always.

Re: So, why are people so focused on a moral right.... 20 Feb 2012 15:13 #51030

There are rules to everything. I believe they are designed to bring order and control. Regardless of whether an individual agrees with them these rules represent the moral right.

I would suppose that people focus on them because being unaware and/or non-compliant creates a huge margin for chaos.

Fawks84, what are some specific examples of those moral rights that the majority does not agree with? Maybe we can narrow the scope of this discussion a bit and identify the details.



Re: So, why are people so focused on a moral right.... 20 Feb 2012 17:08 #51037

I think its just part of a society's syndrome of trying to "dominate" itself like it tries to "dominate" the world around it, just part of the sherade of ideas about what "good" and "bad" is, ideas in which we've come to define with our limited perceptions, and we slowly begin to realize just how subjective the ideas of "good" and "bad" really are. What's good for me may certainly not be good for you. It's just our attempt at trying to grasp two polar ends of a reality in which we think good and bad is separate and in which we think one should win over the other. The subjectivity of good and bad, and thus, of moral ideas should come to show that this is and always will be impossible and that both sides are one in the same, interdependent, and that trying to constantly win one side over the other only strengthens the opposition, thus we serve ourselves up another plate of war and politics.
Last Edit: 20 Feb 2012 17:08 by Proteus.

Re: So, why are people so focused on a moral right.... 20 Feb 2012 23:16 #51051

I seem to remember this conversation taking place somewhere before... strangest case of deja vu. :ohmy:

Almost positive this question or one very similar comes up on a regular basis. Since we can't form an opinion to have a discussion with based on vague facts, please define some of these morals, or moral forays, that you are referring to Fawks.
Last Edit: 20 Feb 2012 23:17 by Viskhard.

Re: So, why are people so focused on a moral right 21 Feb 2012 02:09 #51065

  • Macros
  • Macros's Avatar
In "The Book," we learn that there can be no morality with out immorality, for we cannot perceive one without the other. Both extremes are present in all people, and this is where one must make a choice.

The Hermetic principle of polarity states that these two extremes are the same thing differing only in degree, and rate of vibration. Therefore if you focus on increasing your own rate of vibration, you will be moral. If you focus on decreasing it, you will be immoral.

So, why are people so focused on a moral right.... 21 Feb 2012 02:25 #51072

  • Reliah
  • Reliah's Avatar
  • Knight
  • ID: 8859
I've read people speaking of the "golden rule" and have been taught of a higher rule: treat others the way they desire to be treated. I'm not exactly sure how I feel about either of those rules, to be honest.

Re: So, why are people so focused on a moral right.... 21 Feb 2012 02:29 #51076

The fact of the matter remains, the real purpose of duality of that of balance. Everything we say we believe in as Jedi supports that. All that we do is to geared towards negating a polar opposite, the dark side. We know that we can't get rid of the dark side and we shouldn't want to. We need the dark side just as much as we need air to breathe. We do what we do to keep the dark side in check. I would agree that we should look at morality as trying to attune to a higher vibration. That would make the most sense.

Re: So, why are people so focused on a moral right 21 Feb 2012 03:01 #51083

  • Macros
  • Macros's Avatar
The higher law is more in keeping with the jedi creed.
Latest Posts Comments Articles
    • Is offending a group of people always bad? (Last post by Gisteron)
    • You don't actually know what begging the question means, do you? Here, let me show you: Quote: Offending people places the offender in the wrong of injustice who must compensate the victim to restore the balance of justice. Quote: The past must be balanced? Doesn't this tie your actions? Quote: Justice is about fairness, so if you wronged someone, you must compensate them fairly. It's a very simple concept. Quote: It is a simple concept. But like most things, it is only simple at face value. Tell me... can you decide what is fair so that all will agree? And furthermore, what if there is no one to compensate? IE, they are dead and leave behind no family, friends or loved ones? And what if compensation is not the answer but reconciliation is desired? They are close but not the same. And what is to detour one from wronging another a second time? Or more times. Quote: Why do you say that Justice [sic] is about fairness and why do you say that compensation is any part of either? Alternatively, if you define those words in this way, what obliges any person or authority to enforce them, let alone to care? Quote: Justice is simple for people that develop the virtue of character, and difficult for people that have the virtue of character underdeveloped. See? Begging the question is assuming an essential part of the conclusion in the premise. You assert your conclusion, and then when challenged to bring forth an argument in its favour you just paraphrase it, make your argument assume the conclusion from the get-go. Begging the question, dear sir, is the one thing you accused everyone of so far who didn't do it, yet was in the meantime the only thing you did. And then you elegantly finish of by pretty much insulting your challengers with what amounts to either "you are stupid for not grasping the self-evident truthfulness of my assertion" or "your character lacks the necessary virtues to appreciate my moral high ground". And in the midst of all that you have the gall to pretend to be a long overdue educator on matters of reason and logical argument? Give me a break! Generally speaking, we are a fairly patient bunch in this place - some more generous than others - but I wouldn't advise pushing it still, for in the end we don't take kindly to conduct like that...
    • Is belief in democracy required of a Jedi? (RELEVE... (Last post by Cyan Sarden)
    • In my opinion, the problem with Democracy is that you actually have to believe in it (much like in a deity), rather than being able to actually experience it. Today, Democracy is a theoretical concept, an ideal, perhaps, but I've yet to see it in action. I live in a country that is considered "democratic" - the form of state we have in Switzerland is a "direct democracy". It's "direct" in that the population (actually, only a part of the population - foreign passport-holders aren't allowed to vote, even if they've lived here for 50 years) gets to vote on all kinds of stuff. We have about 4 national votes per year here and a plethora of additional ones on a regional level and on community level. It still doesn't work. self-interest, as Alexandre has mentioned, is what dominates each and every vote. Greed, inequality leads to the result that votes usually don't come out in the best interest of the country, but tend to lean in favour of those who yell the loudest. It's an exercise in frustration. So is it necessary to believe in democracy in order to be a Jedi? I'm not sure. I don't believe in it because I have a hard time believing in things that I know don't work. I don't believe in any kind of government system - none of them really work. "Democratic" countries tend to still offer the best outcome for the population, despite their shortcomings - that is something I believe in.
    • Defining Jedi and Sith (Last post by Edan)
    • Quote: Jediism and Satanism are both incredibly broad categories. You define your worldview as elements of those 3, since I would argue they cannot all be reconciled by traditional thought. Only because you do not know what I mean by them ... And therein lies the problem with calling people anything... Jedi, Sith, by using labels one define others by one's personal definitions.
    • Why silence is often the best response to a verbal... (Last post by Entropist)
    • Quote: The title claims that silence is *often* the best response. Which means that there are situations when it isn't. And I gave a personal situation where silence was the best response. Why are you so focused on arguing that silence is never the answer? Which post number did you think had reasons that proved why silence was the best response in the given example? I ask because there wasn't any justification or rationale why silence was the best response to the example, rather the example was begged. I need to know which post number to reply to in order to substitute this response with.
    • Rants far and wide (Last post by Snowy Aftermath)
    • Super excited for the constant reminder that no matter how much effort I put in, I will always be an outsider, I have done exactly nothing of worth here, and no matter how much I change people will never give me a chance to be different. All that matters is who I was when I first walked in. YAY! Thanks TotJO!
    • Your Jedi Rituals (Last post by Lleiffermawr)
    • Greetings, As a student of psychology, I understand that many people need ritual to help change their state of consciousness. They may need it to instill a calm and peace that goes deeper than a few breaths and the recitation of the Code. Rituals are as old as time and help not only the individual but the community as a whole. Knowing that there are a few things besides a name and a basic philosophy that holds you together can be very inspiring. Some of the most ancient rituals of course revolve around Rites of Passage, including coming of age. There are sometimes rituals for new beginnings such as Initiations (to start something), or becoming an Elder (whether due to age or due to respect for one's knowledge and wisdom). Sometimes these rituals are to achieve some goal (such as in the case of folk magic or even the rites of the Catholic Church). Rituals can be highly personal, as well as collective. They can help to tap into the Collective Unconsciousness of one's ancestors and even mankind at large. I have a long history in the Current of the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn, as well as having spent much time working in Wicca and Traditional Witchcraft (Heathenry). I have noticed that the more in depth the ritual, the deeper I go within myself, and I can feel connection with All That Is (the Unifying Living Force) greater than the simple Circle Casting and Invocation I found in my previous Coven. Some people find Rituals to be constricting, and this can indeed happen. While in some ways, I need such, I recognize that this is indeed a crutch, and some day, I will be able to move away from it. I would be very interested in collective based rituals for the Temple of the Jedi Order itself, would help to inspire a sense of community.
    • The Grateful Thread (Last post by Edan)
    • I'm grateful to the previous gentleman for all of his help :) One day I will have felt like I've said it enough times (or maybe not!).
    • Your Jedi Reading List (Last post by MadHatter)
    • To mark International Jedi Day I am going to post my reading list that I have read or is in my to read queue that I feel has helped or will help me on my path. Please feel free to add your own Hatters Reading List * George Washingtons Rules of Civility and Behavior * Open your mind Open your life (Taro Gold) * Essential Zen ( Kazuaki Tanahashi) * Zen Flesh Zen Bones ( Paul Reps) * The Code of the Samuria (Thomas Cleary) * Zen in the Martial Arts ( Joe Hyams) * Striking Thoughts (Bruce Lee) * The Tao of Jeet Jun Do (Bruce Lee) * The Jedi Compass ( Multiple Authors) * Living the Martial Way (Maj. Forrest E. Morgan) * The Jedi Path ( Chronicle Books) * Zen Mind Beginner's Mind ( Shunryu Suzuki) These are listed in no order other then reading off of my bookshelf. I would love to see your own lists and to share thoughts on the merits of anything listed.
    • International Jedi Day - May 25th! (Last post by Snowy Aftermath)
    • Dagon sent me a message as well: 1) Miss_Leah's idea, only with a more flexible time frame for those who wished to pursue larger projects (or people like me who have to work on the holiday). 2) build a kite from scratch and fly it on the holiday, similar to the tradition in Bermuda of doing the same on Easter Sunday. The idea is that we are all doing it together in widely different areas is very unifying (and in my opinion, the whole point of traditions). I love the kite thing... I might do that too :)
    • Boulimia and sugar (Last post by MartaLina)
    • Quote: ...dont quote me but i think we are the only ones who drink other animals milk. i love yochurt ...
    • Jedi wisdom meme (Last post by MadHatter)
    • This is a meme thread dedicated to wisdom on the Jedi Path. It will seem familiar to those that are frequent visitors to the Temple Facebook page. Ill get us going but I hope to see your Jedi memes on this day dedicated to Jediism and the Path we walk here at the Temple. [attachment] [attachment] [attachment]
    • Simple Gifts (Last post by Joda Sett)
    • Another breath The way the clouds area set ablaze at sunrise The warmth of my daughter’s lips on my cheek A clear summer night Getting lost in the sea of stars to Holt’s “The Planets” The aroma of an open fire Dogwoods in bloom A rainbow of blossoms in the orchards Fresh honey Crisp autumn air A hayride to the pumpkin patch through a colorful forest The bountiful harvest lay out on the dinner table Dancing flakes, drifting to a blanket of white The piercing winter winds The soft glow of lights on the tree A serene sunset The way the beams glisten upon the distant leaves The softness of my furry companion’s coat against me

There are 79 visitors, 5 guests and 17 members online (one in chat): Akkarin, Br. John, Alexandre Orion, Whyte Horse, Cabur Senaar, Aqua, Atticus509, Korvus, Tellahane, Hyrum Tigerprice, Mael, MadHatter, Entropist, Kyrin Wyldstar, Snowy Aftermath, FAT, Diegogarciv, CableSteele, academic_observer, Joda Sett, LiamRevan, Albekl.

Follow Us