Good and Bad Exist?

Moderators: Desolous

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 08:48 #47248

Good and evil exist in nature.
They exist as one.
Thinking separates.

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 09:16 #47252

ichange wrote:
Good and evil exist in nature.
They exist as one.
Thinking separates.

Interesting concept because I believe:

Good and Evil do not exist in nature...
Neither Exist,
Thinking Creates Them!

Let me add - Humans thinking creates them!
Jedi Knight
Deacon of the Temple of the Jedi Order

Master: Mark Anjuu
Former Apprentice / Knight: Jedi Knight Arcade, Jedi Knight J-Roz
Current Apprentices: Jake_Sato, JLSpinner, and cmwatts
Read what I wrote not with your emotion and interpretation, but with mine!
Phortis Nespin
"Right and wrong, good and evil, light and dark most of the time, they are illusions that prevent us from perceiving the greater reality. The Jedi have learned to distance themselves from these illusions, to seek the truth beneath the words"
Luke Skywalker
“Selflessness is the only antidote to evil. It provides the light that destroys the dark.”
Corran Horn
Last Edit: 06 Jan 2012 09:18 by Phortis Nespin.

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 10:26 #47261

  • Adder
  • Adder's Avatar
  • NOW ONLINE
  • Knight
  • ID: 7778
Phortis Nespin wrote:
Let me add - Humans thinking creates them!

Do you exclude other animals because you think they cannot comprehend the suffering of others or do you think they are incapable of evil?

I wonder because I dont think its just humans... I extend a capacity for evil to all animals. I'm not sure about insects yet. My cat (and dogs I've known) can be what I consider evil. I know it's instinct is to hunt to eat, but it routinely tries to practise hunting for fun. Training is good to an extent, but it doesnt really care between the pain and suffering of its victim and so for me that selfishness is comparible to evil. Many animals cause pain and suffering for their own amusement because its a challenge and I think instinctually predators sense the need to kill prey at every opportunity to avoid periods when no prey is available. The key is I think they are smart enough to control themselves and decide not too.
Last Edit: 06 Jan 2012 10:29 by Adder.

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 11:00 #47264

I know that animals have feelings; and, I am certain all intelligent life perceives at least some array of emotion. But I do not feel that all animals perceive good and evil.

These are concepts of morality are based on a dualistic structure. Free will has been accredited with the creation of concepts associated with positive and negative influences. Social acceptance governs the terms that regulate the combining of actions into the moral structure of what is good and what is evil. And what is good in one culture is sometimes not in another.

All life has free will. All life has intelligence. But a complete understanding of each creatures social structure is still foreign to us. So, I believe it is a bit presumptuous for us to associate human characteristics to things we do not fully comprehend.

Yes, there are events which to us seem to cause emotional responses in the behavior of animals; both positive and negative. And I believe the animals understand the difference between joy and sadness, love and hate. But do they see certain events, behaviors and actions as good or evil... probably not. And not because they are not capable of such a level of experience but because they are most likely not experiencing life with the same social structures as us.

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 11:04 #47265

I have pondered the question of whether animals are good or evil and have come to the conclusion that they are not. Animals are capable of so many "emotions" that are similar to that of humans. Dolphins are a prime example of extending emotion towards humans who have had emergencies while in the ocean. And although other animals, especially dogs and cats, have what seem to be human type emotions, I believe they are more instinctual than learned.

I believe what seems like emotion is just a response to a set of circumstances that trigger a instinctual response to display "happy", "sad", "anger", or "fear". I do not believe that nature can be evil or good because they are what they are. It is the human intervention that causes the basic animal to change its response to its surroundings or environment. Besides, if we believe that the Force is not good or evil, and it is our human nature to put labels to things, than???

Believe me, I am on a shaky ledge on this issue so don't beat me up too bad on it. But if I understand what I have been reading, I side with animals are just doing what they do.
Jedi Knight
Deacon of the Temple of the Jedi Order

Master: Mark Anjuu
Former Apprentice / Knight: Jedi Knight Arcade, Jedi Knight J-Roz
Current Apprentices: Jake_Sato, JLSpinner, and cmwatts
Read what I wrote not with your emotion and interpretation, but with mine!
Phortis Nespin
"Right and wrong, good and evil, light and dark most of the time, they are illusions that prevent us from perceiving the greater reality. The Jedi have learned to distance themselves from these illusions, to seek the truth beneath the words"
Luke Skywalker
“Selflessness is the only antidote to evil. It provides the light that destroys the dark.”
Corran Horn

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 11:16 #47267

  • Adder
  • Adder's Avatar
  • NOW ONLINE
  • Knight
  • ID: 7778
Yeah I wouldnt be so presumptious to call any particular animal 'evil' as that sort of judgement would have to be an exageration, but I do have the personal opinion many (possibly all) animals have the capacity for evil behaviours - certainly not all types of evil behaviours, but things like my example above of unnecessarily causing pain and suffering to another creature. I guess you could say I think animals have a light or dark path to choose from just like us!

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 11:32 #47271

I think that all the points discussed are valid. And I agree that animals do things that we consider to be good or evil. And I know that an animal senses when it has done what others perceive as bad. I have seen this every time my dog has an accident in the floor and I give her the “evil eye” :P

I was merely saying that I don't think animals perceive their own actions as good or bad, or the actions of other animals as good or bad; because, I view those as human inventions.

But hey, I could be completely wrong! I am just drawing from what I have experienced. And I would love to set down and discus philosophy with an animal or insect or plant. And I'm not being sarcastic. I would love to know just what does go on in their minds. And maybe someday we will be able to!

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 11:41 #47272

  • Adder
  • Adder's Avatar
  • NOW ONLINE
  • Knight
  • ID: 7778
Wescli Wardest wrote:
I was merely saying that I don't think animals perceive their own actions as good or bad, or the actions of other animals as good or bad; because, I view those as human inventions.

Ahh ok, interesting. I guess I view concepts of evil as objective (if thats the right word) and linked to spirituality through physical welfare, wheras good and bad are more subjective, for me evil is at another level and any living creature would (might) have the ability to have a connection to it (the Force) by virtue of being sentient. I do feel though that animals have a harder time reaching a level of understanding of the Force because they are seemingly so much more driven by instinct then humans.

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 12:08 #47275

Why is it that every time I think of good and evil, it draws me back to the Dungeons and Dragons game? Good, Evil, Neutral Good, Neutral evil, Chaotic Good, Chaotic Evil, etc.

Then another though occurred, good vs bad is different from GOOD vs EVIL.

Some children are bad and some are good, but an evil child gets exorcized.:P
Jedi Knight
Deacon of the Temple of the Jedi Order

Master: Mark Anjuu
Former Apprentice / Knight: Jedi Knight Arcade, Jedi Knight J-Roz
Current Apprentices: Jake_Sato, JLSpinner, and cmwatts
Read what I wrote not with your emotion and interpretation, but with mine!
Phortis Nespin
"Right and wrong, good and evil, light and dark most of the time, they are illusions that prevent us from perceiving the greater reality. The Jedi have learned to distance themselves from these illusions, to seek the truth beneath the words"
Luke Skywalker
“Selflessness is the only antidote to evil. It provides the light that destroys the dark.”
Corran Horn

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 19:37 #47291

Lmao!! That's clever!
Latest Posts Comments Sermons
    • the IP Purpose (Last post by carlos.martinez3)
    • Quote: Basic indoctrination to TOTJO-style thought regurgitation. :) Can u elaborate for the rest of the class, mainly....me? That actually doesn't sound at all fitting. As a whole I've asked our community to come together here and make a real style application to the actual application to the ip. Regurgitation seems to not be the idea, but maybe a more opening of things maybe some have never heard of or even thought possible. I know for myself I had never heard of Allen watts till I got here. Although I don't see eye to eye with a lot pm what I've read the jem I think can be... we can think like that? There's an outside to the box? Hmm mm.
    • SpaceX's plan to colonize Mars (Last post by Sven One)
    • I think it's great! I would like to visit or at least go out into space one time before I return to The Force. I would be happy with going to the moon because it's closer but, if Mars is the place to be sign me up! just make sure to bring plenty of food! LOL
    • Jedi ism (Last post by carlos.martinez3)
    • Quote: Quote: U know what? I do the exact same thing. I suppose now people will want to have us over for dinner, since they know we'll gladly do the dishes :laugh: Dude u have no idea. My syncritism also allows different styles of character to abide. Aka I am VERY Hobbit like. I graduated from the culinary arts in Austin TX. And a few bar tending academies. So I can safely say I'm kitchen folk. I'll go over to friends family and immediately begin washing dishes stowing things and making something to eat or Serve something in a glass over rocks.
    • Show me yours and ill show u mine ? (Last post by carlos.martinez3)
    • Quote: What makes a book a Jedi book? Here's my library... [attachment] Here's my religion section which doesn't have all of my religious books, but most of them. [attachment] [attachment] Ps I see your Harry! *giggled a bit. Lol
    • Gratitude for the Kindness of Others (Last post by Adder)
    • For me its disarming oneself, so to allow equanimity in relations with others. Which then allows either compassion or joy to manifest from the interaction. That is how I tend to view the function of the Brahmavihara - a type of stabilization and operating modality to standardize ones view and conduct as a basis to refine awareness and reaction. From there the doctrine of emptiness can be employed quite easily, to explore the doctrine of two truths etc etc. Don't quote me though, that is just me!!
    • Interesting volunteering orientated questions (ope... (Last post by Adder)
    • 1) What makes someone vulnerable? Ok, not so much about how they became vulnerable but rather the circumstances defining the vulnerabilities. I just find it easier to then move to problem solving from there. So something along the lines of a need which cannot be met, the key measures being the intensity of need and urgency of it being met - to allow prioritization and all that. 2) What is the opposite of vulnerability? Nominality :lol: being nominal - normal, functional. 3) What makes someone the opposite of vulnerable? A combination of things like preparedness, conscientiousness, luck, support, endurance, intelligence, creativity, awareness etc etc. 4) How do we help/support people / What's our role? Education, honesty, transparency, hard work, engagement, responsibility, that sort of stuff!?
    • How being alone may be the key to rest (Last post by Goken)
    • I do believe that the title of the article is something of a leap from what the data actually shows. That's no surprise, however. How many times do articles about scientific studies exaggerate a bit or make a claim only partially supported by the data of the study? All the time. It's about getting clicks more than accurately representing the study. Plus, this was a survey (I'm assuming done online) and it purposefully didn't define the words it was using so that the takers were able to put forth their own meaning. That means that they could all be answering under different interpretations of words like "restful" and "well rested" or "well being." I find it hard to take the findings here too seriously. That said, I would actually agree completely with it. Even spending time with some of my best friends can be draining. I even look forwards to time away from my wife! (don't tell her :unsure: :laugh: ) Sometimes the only way for me to feel fully recharged is to be alone for a while. Personally though, I don't like being alone for very long. Not even a full day. I like having a day off in the middle of the week to do nothing, watch movies my wife hates while eating food she can't stand the smell of. Then by the time she comes home I'm charged and super happy to see her. I'll avoid making plans with friends on days that I had set aside to just be alone. I like what Cayce said though about some people not being 'people.' It makes total sense to me. For example, I have two really close friends. One of whom I can hang out with for hours on end with no problem. We were roommates once and it was great. The other though, I can't really hang out with for as long. We also were roommates once (at the same time as the other actually) and it did not work out as well.
    • Preparing for a Lecture (Last post by Adder)
    • Quote: No pressure. ;) Crikey, no kidding :ohmy: Handstands, lots of handstands :silly: That's awesome, no matter how it turns out big congratulations for the effort!! Though your question is a little massive... off the top of my head; - rationalizing perception, movement and change (procedural efficiency) - connecting emotions to perception (getting in touch) - doctrine of emptiness (not needing to be in touch) - doctrine of two truths (changing the inner narrative) - systems thinking (penetration of ritual) - physio-synthesis (merging body with mind) .. as categories of spiritual focus, but with allied learnings to relate to outer social and historical realities which define the present.
    • Cultural Sensitivity/Appropriation and Anger (Last post by r3dleader)
    • I think that it goes back to cultural appropriation vs cultural misappropriation. It's kind of constructive vs destructive in a grossly oversimplified way that doesn't really scratch the surface. Also, hip-hop culture isn't race based. I'm sure that there are some who think it is, but it's not. It comes from a common shared experience and outlook. That's my 2 cents on that. Now the mascot thing, that's because it is racist. It's offensive to my culture, sure, but the insult to my race is what gets me turned up about it. My culture isn't the same as a Cree's or Lakota's or Navajo's, but my race is. We all get smashed together, so for people to stand there and say it's not that big of a deal... Would it be ok if those people wore shirts that said Washington Niggers and had on blackface on national TV and talked about it how it is their right and they are just honoring the history of African Americans? Do the Chicken Jig and sing spirituals when they rallied? Then why is ok for them to do it to us?
    • To vote, or not to vote... (Last post by Zenchi)
    • Quote: I imagine people who don't currently vote might feel differently if the choice to vote or not was suddenly made for them. That's already a reality in the states, and has been the case ever since swing states were allowed to hold more sway than other states. As long as people vote, it's a proclamation that they approve the choices that's offered to them. It's a vote for the continuation of the status quo, a belief that the system works. Look at our choices, is this a healthy example of a system that is working in our benifit? There are two people running for presidency that are not allowed in the big debates, why? Because they "failed" to bring in enough attention. Why? Because they didnt have the deep pockets to get air time. As long as the "diplomatic process" currently in place in the States (and around the world) is dependent on the all mighty dollar to fuel itself, it will stay corrupted... As long as the poorer of the two remain in the shadows, who will bat an eye at a fixed election? I just dont trust the system anymore....
    • Leaders Eat Last (Leadership in Jediism) (Last post by Senan)
    • When it comes to describing a good leader, I am always reminded of a quote from an anonymous soldier that described the leadership style of U.S. Civil War General and Irish revolutionary Thomas Francis Meagher. "It was never 'go boys, go', but 'come boys, follow me'". To be an effective leader, you must be willing to set an example and do whatever it is you would ask those under your authority to do. It is important to delegate, but you must be ready to get your own hands dirty as well. As Jedi, we can set an example and we can encourage others to follow, but it is more important that we are always also doing the work ourselves.
    • Who is God to you? (Last post by Leah Starspectre)
    • Quote: @leah well, I have always been taught it isn't about you its about Jesus. Would this change or challenge my faith in Christ? Nope, not at all. Jesus Christ I will always have in my heart. The church structure no. I grow tired of hearing people say how much they love God yet, they bash each other and are at times the most hypocritical group of people myself included in this I have done it as well. Espically, when someone leaves church. But, when they're in church they loved them so...obviously not! And I hate to bash others but, it makes me think. Is leaving as horrible as I think? Or, is it a mind over matter deal. That's what I'm suggesting. No matter where you are, you will have your love for Christ with you, so it should be a no-brainer. Although inspired by God, any church you go to was built by Man, and so, is subject to Man's failings and weaknesses (like petty behaviour and misinterpretations of the Word) If you feel like a church isn't embracing the ideals that you believe in, like tolerance and compassion, you're not at fault for wanting to leave. You can leave them to their cattiness and gossip and either find a new fellowship or worship on your own terms. We were given free will for a reason. ;)

There are 314 visitors, 4 guests and 25 members online (2  in chat): Firewolf, J_Roz, Trisskar, Adder, Proteus, Lykeios, Brenna, Llama Su, Kit, Avalonslight, Namid, Cabur Senaar, Atticus, Seda Arksmen, JLSpinner, Ke JinnDakken, MadHatter, Gwinn, Kyrin Wyldstar, Leah Starspectre, Arisaig, Jaxz, Parnerium, ben.quick, Genoe Jhalam, mlessem.

Follow Us