Good and Bad Exist?

Moderators: Desolous, Reliah

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 08:48 #47248

Good and evil exist in nature.
They exist as one.
Thinking separates.

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 09:16 #47252

ichange wrote:
Good and evil exist in nature.
They exist as one.
Thinking separates.

Interesting concept because I believe:

Good and Evil do not exist in nature...
Neither Exist,
Thinking Creates Them!

Let me add - Humans thinking creates them!
Jedi Knight
Deacon of the Temple of the Jedi Order

Master: Mark Anjuu
Former Apprentice / Knight: Jedi Knight Arcade, Jedi Knight Jedi_Roz
Current Apprentices: Jake_Sato, JLSpinner, and cmwatts
Read what I wrote not with your emotion and interpretation, but with mine!
Phortis Nespin
"Right and wrong, good and evil, light and dark most of the time, they are illusions that prevent us from perceiving the greater reality. The Jedi have learned to distance themselves from these illusions, to seek the truth beneath the words"
Luke Skywalker
“Selflessness is the only antidote to evil. It provides the light that destroys the dark.”
Corran Horn
Last Edit: 06 Jan 2012 09:18 by Phortis Nespin.

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 10:26 #47261

  • Adder
  • Adder's Avatar
  • NOW ONLINE
  • Knight
  • ID: 7778
Phortis Nespin wrote:
Let me add - Humans thinking creates them!

Do you exclude other animals because you think they cannot comprehend the suffering of others or do you think they are incapable of evil?

I wonder because I dont think its just humans... I extend a capacity for evil to all animals. I'm not sure about insects yet. My cat (and dogs I've known) can be what I consider evil. I know it's instinct is to hunt to eat, but it routinely tries to practise hunting for fun. Training is good to an extent, but it doesnt really care between the pain and suffering of its victim and so for me that selfishness is comparible to evil. Many animals cause pain and suffering for their own amusement because its a challenge and I think instinctually predators sense the need to kill prey at every opportunity to avoid periods when no prey is available. The key is I think they are smart enough to control themselves and decide not too.
Last Edit: 06 Jan 2012 10:29 by Adder.

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 11:00 #47264

I know that animals have feelings; and, I am certain all intelligent life perceives at least some array of emotion. But I do not feel that all animals perceive good and evil.

These are concepts of morality are based on a dualistic structure. Free will has been accredited with the creation of concepts associated with positive and negative influences. Social acceptance governs the terms that regulate the combining of actions into the moral structure of what is good and what is evil. And what is good in one culture is sometimes not in another.

All life has free will. All life has intelligence. But a complete understanding of each creatures social structure is still foreign to us. So, I believe it is a bit presumptuous for us to associate human characteristics to things we do not fully comprehend.

Yes, there are events which to us seem to cause emotional responses in the behavior of animals; both positive and negative. And I believe the animals understand the difference between joy and sadness, love and hate. But do they see certain events, behaviors and actions as good or evil... probably not. And not because they are not capable of such a level of experience but because they are most likely not experiencing life with the same social structures as us.

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 11:04 #47265

I have pondered the question of whether animals are good or evil and have come to the conclusion that they are not. Animals are capable of so many "emotions" that are similar to that of humans. Dolphins are a prime example of extending emotion towards humans who have had emergencies while in the ocean. And although other animals, especially dogs and cats, have what seem to be human type emotions, I believe they are more instinctual than learned.

I believe what seems like emotion is just a response to a set of circumstances that trigger a instinctual response to display "happy", "sad", "anger", or "fear". I do not believe that nature can be evil or good because they are what they are. It is the human intervention that causes the basic animal to change its response to its surroundings or environment. Besides, if we believe that the Force is not good or evil, and it is our human nature to put labels to things, than???

Believe me, I am on a shaky ledge on this issue so don't beat me up too bad on it. But if I understand what I have been reading, I side with animals are just doing what they do.
Jedi Knight
Deacon of the Temple of the Jedi Order

Master: Mark Anjuu
Former Apprentice / Knight: Jedi Knight Arcade, Jedi Knight Jedi_Roz
Current Apprentices: Jake_Sato, JLSpinner, and cmwatts
Read what I wrote not with your emotion and interpretation, but with mine!
Phortis Nespin
"Right and wrong, good and evil, light and dark most of the time, they are illusions that prevent us from perceiving the greater reality. The Jedi have learned to distance themselves from these illusions, to seek the truth beneath the words"
Luke Skywalker
“Selflessness is the only antidote to evil. It provides the light that destroys the dark.”
Corran Horn

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 11:16 #47267

  • Adder
  • Adder's Avatar
  • NOW ONLINE
  • Knight
  • ID: 7778
Yeah I wouldnt be so presumptious to call any particular animal 'evil' as that sort of judgement would have to be an exageration, but I do have the personal opinion many (possibly all) animals have the capacity for evil behaviours - certainly not all types of evil behaviours, but things like my example above of unnecessarily causing pain and suffering to another creature. I guess you could say I think animals have a light or dark path to choose from just like us!

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 11:32 #47271

I think that all the points discussed are valid. And I agree that animals do things that we consider to be good or evil. And I know that an animal senses when it has done what others perceive as bad. I have seen this every time my dog has an accident in the floor and I give her the “evil eye” :P

I was merely saying that I don't think animals perceive their own actions as good or bad, or the actions of other animals as good or bad; because, I view those as human inventions.

But hey, I could be completely wrong! I am just drawing from what I have experienced. And I would love to set down and discus philosophy with an animal or insect or plant. And I'm not being sarcastic. I would love to know just what does go on in their minds. And maybe someday we will be able to!

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 11:41 #47272

  • Adder
  • Adder's Avatar
  • NOW ONLINE
  • Knight
  • ID: 7778
Wescli Wardest wrote:
I was merely saying that I don't think animals perceive their own actions as good or bad, or the actions of other animals as good or bad; because, I view those as human inventions.

Ahh ok, interesting. I guess I view concepts of evil as objective (if thats the right word) and linked to spirituality through physical welfare, wheras good and bad are more subjective, for me evil is at another level and any living creature would (might) have the ability to have a connection to it (the Force) by virtue of being sentient. I do feel though that animals have a harder time reaching a level of understanding of the Force because they are seemingly so much more driven by instinct then humans.

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 12:08 #47275

Why is it that every time I think of good and evil, it draws me back to the Dungeons and Dragons game? Good, Evil, Neutral Good, Neutral evil, Chaotic Good, Chaotic Evil, etc.

Then another though occurred, good vs bad is different from GOOD vs EVIL.

Some children are bad and some are good, but an evil child gets exorcized.:P
Jedi Knight
Deacon of the Temple of the Jedi Order

Master: Mark Anjuu
Former Apprentice / Knight: Jedi Knight Arcade, Jedi Knight Jedi_Roz
Current Apprentices: Jake_Sato, JLSpinner, and cmwatts
Read what I wrote not with your emotion and interpretation, but with mine!
Phortis Nespin
"Right and wrong, good and evil, light and dark most of the time, they are illusions that prevent us from perceiving the greater reality. The Jedi have learned to distance themselves from these illusions, to seek the truth beneath the words"
Luke Skywalker
“Selflessness is the only antidote to evil. It provides the light that destroys the dark.”
Corran Horn

Re: Good and Bad Exist? 06 Jan 2012 19:37 #47291

Lmao!! That's clever!
Latest Posts Comments Articles
    • Force Realist TV (Last post by Lleiffermawr)
    • Greetings, The first thing I learned back when I first became a Freemason, which I have brought with me in any spiritual, philosophical, or religious group I have become a part of is that one's political views, should not be focused upon specific candidates or political parties, but more on the issues themselves, and certainly we have a right to our own views, but that sometimes it is better NOT to bring them up. Not because they do not matter. But because they may matter to us TOO much. We become attached to the expectations that our personal views SHOULD be shared with others, and by that I mean that they should agree with us. When they do not agree with us, that is when the natural reaction is to become angry, and thus, lose our sense of balance. That is when disagreements turn heated. We have the joy of living in a Republic, which champions a democratic method of choice. We choose our Senators and Representatives, who in turn vote according to their own views, which they try to mimic what the majority of their constituents decide it legal. We must also remember that what is legal isn't necessarily right. There is a difference between legal and moral or ethical. Thank you for sharing this video, it has given me a lot to meditate upon tonight. And I feel you have touched on something important for all Jedi to take a look at.
    • Is offending a group of people always bad? (Last post by Entropist)
    • Quote: My issue is with causing another living entity to suffer because it is thought to make it taste better. But there is no dehumanization being done. And the only reason I wrote the people I did is because they are the ones that could implement change in their areas. :) This is exactly the crux of the discussion, however, generalising an entire ethinicity as a means of identification, erases individuality as means of dehumanisation. So yes dehumanisation by generalisation and racial prejudice is clearly committed from the start in this thread. No one is saying you, so there's no reason to identify with relevance; we are only talking about the issues of the topic. The two concepts are inappropriately and unreasonably mixed, therefore is a means of racial prejudice. As a result, the thread needs to choose to stay on the topic of offending people; or create another topic on torture, and racial prejudice. Quote: As to justice… I agreed that the idea of justice is simple. It is in the execution that degrees of difficulty are found. And I explained why that is so. And I explained why because the concept of “fair” may be universally translated but again, its execution is not universally agreed on. And that is why we are having the debate we are having now. In China, there is a group of people that believe their treatment of a life form is fair and I do not. :dry: Only good reason will support a claim. So please refer me to the post number where you explained where the practice of justice is difficult? The context is offenders that committed a wrong is clear and simple, and therefore always bad. But, if someone were to disagree that offenders are not always bad; let the reason speak to support the claim, otherwise the claim is unfounded and unsupported by reason; i.e. unreasonable
    • From time to time a poem (Last post by Edan)
    • Another one... The sun was rising above the city; I sat on the rooftop of the cathedral, leaning back on my elbows, admiring the bleeding of red and orange sun into a lightening blue sky. The people down below, the few who were out, were small and difficult to make out. I had watched them only briefly when the terracotta tiles had first become my seat. There was a slight breeze rustling leaves, and a pleasant chill to the air, the smell of the morning waking up the world. Footsteps behind, then the familiar presence joined me at the edge. “This is an unusual spot for you” he noted, as he sat himself, legs dangling, over the edge of the roof. “Sometimes I need to remind myself the light is there” I replied, and it was especially beautiful this particular morning. “Pensive?” “Always.” “So tell me about it.” It didn’t matter where I was or what I was doing, there was a warmth to his words that always comforted. Minutes in his company, or hours, he always had the time, exactly the right time, to listen. “Whenever I think I have solved my issues with how I feel, I find that I in fact simply moved them about a bit.” “Well,” he replied, admiring the sun briefly, “that is because it is not a problem that has a solution, as you think.” He tensed a little, “you see, whenever we talk you go away feeling that you’re somehow a little broken still. You put those feelings to the back of your mind and you leave here for a while, you go out into the world and be one of those little people below." There was a shout below us, both looking down to see its origin, it faded, and our attentions returned. “You hold everything in, retreating into yourself so you can be ‘normal’ for just a little while. But then who you really are starts to gain strength again, slowly taking hold and for a while you own that.” Listening was hard and I found that I couldn’t look at him as he spoke, my focus honed on birds on a distant rooftop. “Look at me!” Momentarily I paused, before I broke my gaze and slowly met his eyes. “But, you let the fear of being strange beat you down again. And in the shadows you show yourself only to the little flame, before extinguishing it once the day is done.” He leaned forward and took my hand with both of his, “Be you! In all that you are, in all that you believe, seize it! And don’t be afraid."
    • [Science] - Free will could all be an illusion (Last post by OB1Shinobi)
    • Quote: Thank you for that... "you have the destiny to live out your free will choices" Thats what I have said, lol... :) Edit: Imma watch that tonight... :) id be interested to "hear" your thoughts on it if you do get the chance to watch it and no worries if you dont its a great lecture imo, he always covers a lot of material in his talks, this is one of my favorites, because explains how the big five model of personality came to be, the value of introversion vs extroversion, gives an easy to understand intro to brain and nervous system function, human echolocation and the likely origins of the blind swordsman myth, and the western explanation of maya you should watch this video because he plays it in the lecture but we cant see it, its less than 2 minutes youve probably seen it or at least something like it, but its good to refresh and if you havent seen this version yet you might enjoy it
    • Aqua`s Art Gallery (Last post by Aqua)
    • Horse walk above the clouds: The empty dream journey, a time of silence fly with me, over my clouds hear the wind blowing over your wings hear the wings moving in the air journey in cloud, flight on horseback my emptiness the noble horse Pegasus wild and gentle, moving trough fields bringer of lightning, walk the sky show me your wings Aqua, 26-05-2016
    • Question of the Day (Last post by MadHatter)
    • I have received permission from Knight Reliah to post here until she is back from leave. So today's question of the day is: Do you think the world will be a better or worse place in 100 years from now? Why? Please answer in your own journal.
    • Recipes and Goals (Just a thought) (Last post by Snowy Aftermath)
    • I made this: www.kingarthurflour.com/recipes/county-fair-fried-dough-recipe about an hour ago with a teeeeny tiny bit of sugar on it and it was SO FREAKIN' GOOD. And I was thinking, next time I'm going to dip it in marinara sauce. Then I'm going to have it with tuna salad in the middle. Then stuff for a taco spread out on it. Really it was good. And easy. And best of all the ingredients list is tiny (I never have anything in the house, so this is an important one). Just make sure the oil is hot enough when you drop it in... and don't burn yourself (I did because I'm a noob). I know this wasn't the point of your thread, but I had a good experience and wanted to share xD
    • Why silence is often the best response to a verbal... (Last post by Brick)
    • Quote: The irony of this entire dialogue is that perhaps the best way to resolve any differences of opinion or to prove the reasonable and logical legitimacy of claims made here would be silence from everyone going forward. :whistle: :laugh:
    • Homosexuality. (Last post by Alethea Thompson)
    • Another piece that was agreed upon across the community, from a document called "The Jedi Compass" - Quote: Tolerance- You do not need to agree with someone's religion, their nationality, their career choice, their dress or anything else for that matter. Tolerance is not about agreement, it is about showing respect for the freedom of a persons choices and to respect their choices, until it reaches a point in which a reasonable person would consider the individual's actions as a/an (emotionally, spiritually, financially, and/or physically) abusive threat to you or another person. You might not agree with people being homosexual, but it doesn't hurt anyone- and therefore if you don't agree with it, you must make the decision to let them be homosexual if that makes them happy (I've met Jedi that don't agree with homosexuality, but they have made the decision to not act on their disagreement with such).
    • Jediism Day and a Vow of Silence (Last post by Cyan Sarden)
    • For me, talking is part of my job (I'm a teacher) - and who's going to shout at my kids if not me :-) But I'd still be interesting how things turned out for you? Did you manage to do this the entire day yesterday?
    • Defining Jedi and Sith (Last post by RyuJin)
    • what is a sith? whatever they decide they are... what is a jedi? whatever they decide they are... who are you? whomever you decide you are... who am i? whomever i decide i am... your focus determines your reality...if you believe you need clearly defined parameters to identify the world around you, then only you can clearly define those parameters in a way that you fully understand. most things cannot be clearly defined in a manner that is universally understood....my blue is not the same as everyone else's blue... only in fiction do the sith follow the "rule of two"...in the real world most sith are either fiercely independent, or strong team players...independent ones usually only trust their own abilities to achieve their goals, the team players usually trust that their teammates abilities will aid in achieving their goals... i've been down both paths...both paths can be solitary and internal, both can be communal and external...it is what you make of it, no matter what path you travel...

There are 326 visitors, 5 guests and 29 members online (3  in chat): Br. John, Firewolf, RyuJin, Jestor, J_Roz, ren, Joe, Dechlain, Connor L., Adder, Darren, Avalonslight, Cabur Senaar, FTPC, Lleiffermawr, Atticus509, Adi, forcebeck, Tellahane, MadHatter, Gwinn, Braedon2011, Kyrin Wyldstar, Snowy Aftermath, jpadkins, FAT, Diegogarciv, Miss_Leah, CableSteele, academic_observer, LiamRevan.

Follow Us