Should Jedi (when of age) have CHILDREN??

Moderators: Desolous, Reliah

Re: Should Jedi (when of age) have CHILDREN?? 23 Dec 2011 11:20 #46481

Learn_to_Know wrote:
However, I'm not ready to subscribe to the idea that Jedi should have children. There is much that a Jedi can do in their service and compassion to others that doesn't have to involve raising their own. Perhaps even seeking out those children that are in a less fortunate position and helping them in some way?


As a matter of semantics, should and must are not the same. Jedi should have children but not all have the capacity or capability at this time in their life. I would also point out that working with any child is a form of parenting. If you have a desire to help other children that is wonderful. As a past PTA member I worked with many children in the school. I was also a Scout Master for several years.

In any one of these cases, you are raising children, you just are not paying for their cloths so to speak. Your influence on a child has an effect on them that lasts a lifetime. I have children I worked with 10 years ago saying hi to me in the grocery store. I wish I could remember all their names. They remember me because of the time I took to teach them how to read, or make paper, or chalk. I, in a very real sense, took an active part in raising that child.

So...raise your own or raise others? Either way be a positive role model!
Jedi Knight
Deacon of the Temple of the Jedi Order

Master: Mark Anjuu
Former Apprentice / Knight: Jedi Knight Arcade, Jedi Knight Jedi_Roz
Current Apprentices: Jake_Sato, JLSpinner, and cmwatts
Read what I wrote not with your emotion and interpretation, but with mine!
Phortis Nespin
"Right and wrong, good and evil, light and dark most of the time, they are illusions that prevent us from perceiving the greater reality. The Jedi have learned to distance themselves from these illusions, to seek the truth beneath the words"
Luke Skywalker
“Selflessness is the only antidote to evil. It provides the light that destroys the dark.”
Corran Horn
The following user(s) said Thank You: LTK, Desolous

Re: Should Jedi (when of age) have CHILDREN?? 23 Dec 2011 12:16 #46484

  • LTK
  • LTK's Avatar
  • OFFLINE
  • Knight
  • ID: 8277
Sapadu wrote:
'HAH!' Kendalina guffawed. Immediately, Jack should have known the Vader quote would upset her, 'Redemption for killing, what, THOUSANDS of people, just because he got that stupid b**** senator from Naboo knocked up and she popped out TWO kids? How is that redeeming in the SLIGHTEST?'

"Kendalina, you're not helping your case when I try to defend you as a pro-feminist model." Jack mumbled.

'No, I'm serious. The mother is the one who did all the work, Vader didn't play ANY role in how they grew up -- what with never BEING there or even being AWARE the children had been born or survived -- and he didn't get his head out of his @$$ until the very last second.' Kendalina fumed. Triclops didn't say a word, merely sitting by and knitting, 'And your children being the best of you? KARK THAT! That's just lazy, relying on a kid to justify your existence. You should be a good person on your OWN! Lookit Jango Fett! Having Boba Fett didn't redeem him. Or the Emperor for that matter -- 'cuz, y'know, HE was such a great person because of Trike!'

'The Emperor didn't have kids!' Interrupted Kakeru, in a very Star Trek-not-knowing-Star-Wars-lore sort of voice.

'Sure he did -- but it was in cloning experiments kinda like the Jango/Boba Fett crossed with Frankenstein way.' James snapped back, fanboy to the core. Tired of the argument, Triclops sighed.

'Maybe the real lesson is Vader's ability to love.' It certainly shut everyone up, 'He turned to the Dark Side because the obsessive, violent part of his love for his wife turned into possessiveness. What redeems him is the fact that he loves his son enough to save that son.'

"I like her passion, but I think we disagree on the word redeem," LTK said quietly.

His Force Conscience paused momentarily before prompting softly, "What does redeem mean to you?"

LTK contemplated carefully, debating within himself how to best phrase it. Not being entirely sure of his choice of words, he proceeded cautiously.

"I look at redeem in this scenario with Vader as simply a desire to not repeat the same mistakes again." LTK paused a moment, feeling like he wasn't being as clear as he desired. "He finally turned his back on the darkness, and it was because of the suffering of his son, what he was witnessing that spurred him on. His child may not have redeemed him from his past evils, but he certainly effected a huge change on Vader as he turned against the embodiment of evil. That is kind of like redemption, isn't?"

His Force Conscience nodded sagely, but was somewhat disappointed at LTK's struggling to explain a concept that should be clear and concise. "What about her comment about using a kid to justify your existence. I believe she said you should be a good person on your own, not just because you have a kid."

LTK quickly replied, "I agree with her there. We should be a good person on our own. To have to rely on children to be good would be an attachment a Jedi shouldn't have."

His Force Conscience smiled delightedly. "She is definitely right. And you are on your way to understanding this, possibly as well as she already does. But one thing shouldn't be forgotten: understand that you should be a good person on your own, you should strive to be an even better person when guarding and training a light that comes from the Force."
Master: Jestor
“I have striven not to laugh at human actions, not to weep at them, nor to hate them, but to understand them" -- Baruch Spinoza.

Re: Should Jedi (when of age) have CHILDREN?? 23 Dec 2011 14:41 #46488

  • Leena
  • Leena's Avatar
  • OFFLINE
  • Initiate
  • ID: 1965
I must say I like the question a lot. I agree with Phortis Nespin on this as far as the answer. I would love to have children and plan to when I find the right man to have them with. Now, aside from work, I have taught kids, mentored, and other things. It's so important to be a positive role model.

As for redeeming, that's an interesting point. Can that act of saving his son redeem Vader? Well, acording to some religions, yes. In Islam, I believe Muhammad said that if you do a bad deed followed by a good deed, the good deed will wipe out the bad one. In Christianity, Jesus' sacrifice redeems any who accept him and repent. Is everyone redeemed by their children, no. I think perhaps Vader was. Honestly, their mother didn't do all the work. She had the children and died. They were each raised by different people. It is a testament to Anakin Skywalker that even after he became Darth Vader and didn't know his kids, he still saved Luke's life and, ultimately, sacrificed his own.
Leena
"In times of change the learners will inherit the earth, while the knowers will find themselves beautifully equipped to deal with a world that no longer exists. ” Eric Hoffer
The following user(s) said Thank You: LTK

Re: Should Jedi (when of age) have CHILDREN?? 23 Dec 2011 23:20 #46494

  • RyuJin
  • RyuJin's Avatar
  • OFFLINE
  • Senior Knight
  • Priest
  • ID: 3037
i say, let things happen as they must... if one is meant to have children it will happen (whether they plan to or not). whether we have children or not we should still provide a positive rolemodel to all(adult and children alike).
I do not need a cloak of darkness, I am darkness and I am light. I am both because the universe is both.

sometimes you have to enter the darkness to save the light

In truth, everyone wears a mask. when speaking to others, a false persona can charm, seduce, or frighten. -darth sidious, book of sith-

"did you ever see a lion stretch before taking down a gazelle?" -tallahassee, zombieland-

Warning: Spoiler! [ Click to expand ]
J.l.lawson, knight, b.div, o.c.p
Degree Administrator,Intake officer, Eastern Studies S.I.G advisor
Former masters: GM KanaSeikoHaruki, Br.John
Current Apprentices: Raikoutenshi, Zenchi, Baru
Semper Fortis
Vis Vobiscum

The following user(s) said Thank You: LTK

Re: Should Jedi (when of age) have CHILDREN?? 24 Dec 2011 03:24 #46495

I have 3 daughters and a gran daughter, they are my life!!!

Re: Should Jedi (when of age) have CHILDREN?? 24 Dec 2011 03:59 #46496

I have three fantastic children, I can't think of life without them now.

When my 1st one was on the way I was so very worried as I was not sure I was ready to be a dad, but when are we ever ready ???

Re: Should Jedi (when of age) have CHILDREN?? 24 Dec 2011 16:33 #46502

I don't really agree with Lucas that the point of life is having children- that's what a virus does, not more complex living things. We are more than our children.

However, I am a father myself, and can see the arguments for and against it in my own experiences. Parenting is a valuable teaching experience, and can be a great joy and fulfillment. However, your own body and mind does attempt to betray you and cause you to instinctively center on them. It has proven genetically valuable, but may not be the wisest course of action for a Jedi.

Through application of will, I have gotten to a place where I love my children, but feel no attachment to them, and do not revolve my life around them. Not many parents do all three of those things.

Saying Jedi should have children is something of a loaded statement to something that has advantages and disadvantages. I would say Jedi should be allowed to have children.
Latest Posts Comments Articles
    • Is offending a group of people always bad? (Last post by Gisteron)
    • Quote: Very plain and simple response that directly focuses on the question, which answers the point of offenders engaging in an offensive practice that wrongs others, and is therefore an injustice. As a result, offending a person or a group of people - the title of the thread - by definition is wrong. Plain and simple. So if, say, I were to disagree with you on some matter of justice, like for instance that there is something wrong with offending people, it'd be because my character lacks the fundamental virtue we call "justice" and - by definition - the way we measure that character virtue is by how easily and how often someone agrees with you. Alright, I can see how this is indeed very simple. But I won't cut you any slack here still. This to me sounds nothing like the result of a language barrier. It sounds like both a tightly circular argument and arrogant to extents I couldn't quantify if I tried. You know, perhaps after all I do not have your noble sense of morality, not your smoothness of character or eloquence of speech or skill at logic, but at least for me there are still more things out there to learn, more places to go, more people to meet, more knowledge to gain, and more humanity to grow. [Censored] you, good night! :angry:
    • Recipes and Goals (Just a thought) (Last post by Snowy Aftermath)
    • I made this: www.kingarthurflour.com/recipes/county-fair-fried-dough-recipe about an hour ago with a teeeeny tiny bit of sugar on it and it was SO FREAKIN' GOOD. And I was thinking, next time I'm going to dip it in marinara sauce. Then I'm going to have it with tuna salad in the middle. Then stuff for a taco spread out on it. Really it was good. And easy. And best of all the ingredients list is tiny (I never have anything in the house, so this is an important one). Just make sure the oil is hot enough when you drop it in... and don't burn yourself (I did because I'm a noob). I know this wasn't the point of your thread, but I had a good experience and wanted to share xD
    • Why silence is often the best response to a verbal... (Last post by Brick)
    • Quote: The irony of this entire dialogue is that perhaps the best way to resolve any differences of opinion or to prove the reasonable and logical legitimacy of claims made here would be silence from everyone going forward. :whistle: :laugh:
    • Homosexuality. (Last post by Alethea Thompson)
    • Another piece that was agreed upon across the community, from a document called "The Jedi Compass" - Quote: Tolerance- You do not need to agree with someone's religion, their nationality, their career choice, their dress or anything else for that matter. Tolerance is not about agreement, it is about showing respect for the freedom of a persons choices and to respect their choices, until it reaches a point in which a reasonable person would consider the individual's actions as a/an (emotionally, spiritually, financially, and/or physically) abusive threat to you or another person. You might not agree with people being homosexual, but it doesn't hurt anyone- and therefore if you don't agree with it, you must make the decision to let them be homosexual if that makes them happy (I've met Jedi that don't agree with homosexuality, but they have made the decision to not act on their disagreement with such).
    • Jediism Day and a Vow of Silence (Last post by Cyan Sarden)
    • For me, talking is part of my job (I'm a teacher) - and who's going to shout at my kids if not me :-) But I'd still be interesting how things turned out for you? Did you manage to do this the entire day yesterday?
    • Defining Jedi and Sith (Last post by RyuJin)
    • what is a sith? whatever they decide they are... what is a jedi? whatever they decide they are... who are you? whomever you decide you are... who am i? whomever i decide i am... your focus determines your reality...if you believe you need clearly defined parameters to identify the world around you, then only you can clearly define those parameters in a way that you fully understand. most things cannot be clearly defined in a manner that is universally understood....my blue is not the same as everyone else's blue... only in fiction do the sith follow the "rule of two"...in the real world most sith are either fiercely independent, or strong team players...independent ones usually only trust their own abilities to achieve their goals, the team players usually trust that their teammates abilities will aid in achieving their goals... i've been down both paths...both paths can be solitary and internal, both can be communal and external...it is what you make of it, no matter what path you travel...
    • Is belief in democracy required of a Jedi? (RELEVE... (Last post by Cyan Sarden)
    • In my opinion, the problem with Democracy is that you actually have to believe in it (much like in a deity), rather than being able to actually experience it. Today, Democracy is a theoretical concept, an ideal, perhaps, but I've yet to see it in action. I live in a country that is considered "democratic" - the form of state we have in Switzerland is a "direct democracy". It's "direct" in that the population (actually, only a part of the population - foreign passport-holders aren't allowed to vote, even if they've lived here for 50 years) gets to vote on all kinds of stuff. We have about 4 national votes per year here and a plethora of additional ones on a regional level and on community level. It still doesn't work. self-interest, as Alexandre has mentioned, is what dominates each and every vote. Greed, inequality leads to the result that votes usually don't come out in the best interest of the country, but tend to lean in favour of those who yell the loudest. It's an exercise in frustration. So is it necessary to believe in democracy in order to be a Jedi? I'm not sure. I don't believe in it because I have a hard time believing in things that I know don't work. I don't believe in any kind of government system - none of them really work. "Democratic" countries tend to still offer the best outcome for the population, despite their shortcomings - that is something I believe in.
    • Rants far and wide (Last post by Snowy Aftermath)
    • Super excited for the constant reminder that no matter how much effort I put in, I will always be an outsider, I have done exactly nothing of worth here, and no matter how much I change people will never give me a chance to be different. All that matters is who I was when I first walked in. YAY! Thanks TotJO!
    • Your Jedi Rituals (Last post by Lleiffermawr)
    • Greetings, As a student of psychology, I understand that many people need ritual to help change their state of consciousness. They may need it to instill a calm and peace that goes deeper than a few breaths and the recitation of the Code. Rituals are as old as time and help not only the individual but the community as a whole. Knowing that there are a few things besides a name and a basic philosophy that holds you together can be very inspiring. Some of the most ancient rituals of course revolve around Rites of Passage, including coming of age. There are sometimes rituals for new beginnings such as Initiations (to start something), or becoming an Elder (whether due to age or due to respect for one's knowledge and wisdom). Sometimes these rituals are to achieve some goal (such as in the case of folk magic or even the rites of the Catholic Church). Rituals can be highly personal, as well as collective. They can help to tap into the Collective Unconsciousness of one's ancestors and even mankind at large. I have a long history in the Current of the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn, as well as having spent much time working in Wicca and Traditional Witchcraft (Heathenry). I have noticed that the more in depth the ritual, the deeper I go within myself, and I can feel connection with All That Is (the Unifying Living Force) greater than the simple Circle Casting and Invocation I found in my previous Coven. Some people find Rituals to be constricting, and this can indeed happen. While in some ways, I need such, I recognize that this is indeed a crutch, and some day, I will be able to move away from it. I would be very interested in collective based rituals for the Temple of the Jedi Order itself, would help to inspire a sense of community.
    • Your Jedi Reading List (Last post by MadHatter)
    • To mark International Jedi Day I am going to post my reading list that I have read or is in my to read queue that I feel has helped or will help me on my path. Please feel free to add your own Hatters Reading List * George Washingtons Rules of Civility and Behavior * Open your mind Open your life (Taro Gold) * Essential Zen ( Kazuaki Tanahashi) * Zen Flesh Zen Bones ( Paul Reps) * The Code of the Samuria (Thomas Cleary) * Zen in the Martial Arts ( Joe Hyams) * Striking Thoughts (Bruce Lee) * The Tao of Jeet Jun Do (Bruce Lee) * The Jedi Compass ( Multiple Authors) * Living the Martial Way (Maj. Forrest E. Morgan) * The Jedi Path ( Chronicle Books) * Zen Mind Beginner's Mind ( Shunryu Suzuki) These are listed in no order other then reading off of my bookshelf. I would love to see your own lists and to share thoughts on the merits of anything listed.

There are 123 visitors, 6 guests and 28 members online (4  in chat): Br. John, Firewolf, Jestor, Trisskar, Wescli Wardest, V-Tog, rugadd, Khaos, Senan, Cabur Senaar, Aqua, Slebo, FTPC, Loudzoo, Lleiffermawr, Atticus509, Korvus, Tellahane, Obedient Jedi, Hyrum Tigerprice, dark scarf, MadHatter, MartaLina, Kyrin Wyldstar, Snowy Aftermath, FAT, Ryder, WillowC, Diegogarciv, Miss_Leah, CableSteele, LiamRevan, Albekl.

Follow Us