How Do Jedi View Waterboarding?

Moderators: Adder, Adhara

How Do Jedi View Waterboarding? 25 Apr 2012 18:13 #57793

According to our temple doctrine, "Jedi Believe...In the sanctity of the human person. We oppose the use of torture and cruel or unusual punishment including the death penalty. 1"

I know that waterboarding is a very controversial issue (one that my dad and I always debate), and that the United States military has used waterboarding as a "advanced method of interrogation". I personally believe it is torture, but my dad always disagrees and says that it doesn't cause pain but merely "scares" the person (because he feels like he's drowning.

Moreover, as a Jedi (in training)...

1) I oppose torture and cruel and unusual punishment.
2) I think that waterboarding is torture because it does cause people pain and forces them to answer questions.


3) I oppose waterboarding.

What's your position on this matter? How do other Jedi view waterboarding?

1) Do you oppose any type of torture and cruel and unusual punishment?
2) Do you think waterboarding is torture? (Or just "an advanced form of interrogation"?)
3) (Therefore) Do you oppose or support waterboarding?

Thanks for you opinions, in advance.
Sean Ching - Jedi Apprentice
Teaching Master: Senior Knight V-Tog

Re: How Do Jedi View Waterboarding? 25 Apr 2012 18:17 #57795

One quick tidbit of perspective...

Some of you may ask why in the world would my dad think waterboarding isn't torture? (It seems a bit crazy to me.)

However, here is what I found on wikipedia: specifically about the Bush Administration's use of waterboarding and their justification for using it on suspected terrorists:

"During the presidency of George W. Bush, U.S. government officials at various times said they did not believe waterboarding to be a form of torture.[12][13][14][15] To justify its use of waterboarding, the Bush administration issued classified legal opinions that argued for a narrow definition of torture under U.S. law, including the Bybee memo, which it later withdrew.[16][17][18]"

So, my point is, even though I think that waterboarding is definitely torture (and I'm sure a lot of you also agree), there are many significant people out there that support it and deny that is is torture.

So there are many perspectives. Life is not simple.
Sean Ching - Jedi Apprentice
Teaching Master: Senior Knight V-Tog

Re: How Do Jedi View Waterboarding? 25 Apr 2012 18:21 #57796

  • Darren
  • Darren's Avatar
  • Knight
  • Deacon
  • ID: 8542
I oppose torture and cruel and unusual punishment.
To me, water-boarding is torture. Even if it doesn't cause physical pain, there is emotional and psychological pain involved.
Therefore, I oppose water-boarding.
Rev. Darren M. Baldwin OCP
Knight of Jediism
Deacon of TotJO/Ordained Minister of the Force
Masters: Grandmaster Mark Anjuu, Wescli Wardest, and Alexandre Orion

Re: How Do Jedi View Waterboarding? 25 Apr 2012 18:24 #57799

It is not a punishment... it is torture!

I openly oppose all torture.
Some forms of water boarding are extremely painful... and they not only damage the body, but the psyche. People are never the same afterwards, and people have died a very slow and terrifying death from it.

I believe that the ends never "justify" the means and that we should conduct ourselves accordingly.
I not only cherish human life, but hold a sanctity to all life.

Re: How Do Jedi View Waterboarding? 25 Apr 2012 18:25 #57800

  • NickCB
  • NickCB's Avatar
  • Novice
  • ID: 10295
It would depend how you define torture, if its mental then yes waterboarding is mental torture but it is not physical. Its similar to the water torture of dripping water on someones head although that does cause more physical damage.
The issue is that many see torture as physical and not mental

Re: How Do Jedi View Waterboarding? 25 Apr 2012 18:28 #57802

I don't know that I would call it torture, but in my quickly formed opinion that is subject to change, I think I'm against it simply because it can be a slippery slope to other extreme forms of punishment.

Instead, ask the prisoner what his favorite foods and dessert are. Then just give the prisoner bread and water while you eat their favorite meals everyday in front of them. Do this until they crack. I'd crack on that kind of treatment in about a day.

See? You don't need "aggresive negotiations."

Master: Jestor
Apprentice: Psyddhattha
“I have striven not to laugh at human actions, not to weep at them, nor to hate them, but to understand them" -- Baruch Spinoza.

Re: How Do Jedi View Waterboarding? 25 Apr 2012 18:31 #57803

  • V-Tog
  • V-Tog's Avatar
  • Senior Knight
  • Priest
  • ID: 9122
1) Do you oppose any type of torture and cruel and unusual punishment?

Yes. Who are we to grant ourselves the power to cause other people pain and suffering? My moral code finds the concept of torture abhorrent. And aside from that, what if the person turned out to be innocent?

2) Do you think waterboarding is torture? (Or just "an advanced form of interrogation"?)

Absolutely. It is supposed to simulate drowning, is it not? Imagine what it must feel like to drown - to feel as though your lungs are filling with water and you can't breathe. I wouldn't wish that on my worst enemy.

3) (Therefore) Do you oppose or support waterboarding?

Oppose. Very very strongly.
The following user(s) said Thank You: Wescli Wardest, Harvestpaw

Re: How Do Jedi View Waterboarding? 25 Apr 2012 18:42 #57805

Well, I think we can all agree that waterboarding is something we would not like to do or to be subject of. In my opinion it is clearly a form of torture.

From the linguistical point of view:

If we look the definition of torture up, in the spanish royal language academy dictionary (Real Academia Española de la Lengua), we find the following definition:
Grave dolor físico o psicológico infligido a alguien, con métodos y utensilios diversos, con el fin de obtener de él una confesión, o como medio de castigo. which means: serious physical or psicological pain inflicted to someone with diverse methods and tools, with the goal of obtaaining a confession or as a punishment. therefore wateboading would be a form of torture.

From the moral point of view:

From this point of view another controversy arises, ¿Is it justified in some situations to inflict pain on another person to obtain information which may save a life?. I say to save a life because I believe that the right to live is the highest one there is, and therefore the only one that may justify moraly wrong actions like forms of torture, or even terminating another life (self defence), when my right to live conflicts with the right to live of another.

Any other situation where torture is applied for other reasons I cannot justify. For me only life is worth enough to corrupt our behaviour in such a way.

1. I oppose forms of torture and unsusual punishment. The only exception I see is that as a result of it a life may be saved.
2.Yes, I think waterboarding is torture
3. I totally oppose this type of torturing. Appart from beeing a form of torture, it is also too aggressive, and may therefore cause not only permanent psicologycal damage (trauma) but also death if not done "right".

Re: How Do Jedi View Waterboarding? 26 Apr 2012 15:54 #57900

  • Akkarin
  • Akkarin's Avatar
  • Councillor
  • Priest
  • ID: 484
Any other situation where torture is applied for other reasons I cannot justify. For me only life is worth enough to corrupt our behaviour in such a way.

You think it's worth it when we corrupt our behaviour? How is it you think that it's possible to have larger ideals if the smaller ones get compromised?

It's like building a house without a foundation. Sooner or later it will collapse.
V-Tog wrote:
1) Do you oppose any type of torture and cruel and unusual punishment?

Yes. Who are we to grant ourselves the power to cause other people pain and suffering? My moral code finds the concept of torture abhorrent. And aside from that, what if the person turned out to be innocent?

2) Do you think waterboarding is torture? (Or just "an advanced form of interrogation"?)

Absolutely. It is supposed to simulate drowning, is it not? Imagine what it must feel like to drown - to feel as though your lungs are filling with water and you can't breathe. I wouldn't wish that on my worst enemy.

3) (Therefore) Do you oppose or support waterboarding?

Oppose. Very very strongly.

That is my view exactly
Sean Ching via Wikipedia wrote:
the Bush administration issued classified legal opinions that argued for a narrow definition of torture under U.S. law

That is simply using the letter of the law to defeat the spirit of the law
Apprentices: discorder, hellisforhorses, Red Lila
Former Apprentices: Desolous
Former Master: Br. John

Head of Public Relations and Marketing
Associate Pastor

Senior Knight and Priest of the Temple of the Jedi Order
The following user(s) said Thank You: V-Tog

Re: How Do Jedi View Waterboarding? 26 Apr 2012 15:59 #57901

Anyone that considers waterboarding not torturous should be waterboarded themselves- and I happen to like Bush (not getting into politics here, so don't start).

I am against waterboarding and torture- with the exception of withholding "treats" (soda, chai, tobacco, etc).
Alethea "Setanaoko" Thompson
Apprentice to Br. John

"Stop praying. Praying is a sense of false accomplishment, thus leading you to inaction. If you stop praying, you will be driven to take action, which in the end will prove more effective." - Nathan Thompson
Latest Posts Comments Articles
    • Philosophy Tech Support (Last post by Rickie The Grey)
    • Quote: Sometimes I feel like the comic I read was something entirely different from the one that was posted :blink: I just took it to mean suckie customer service but that may because I deal with stuff like that at work. It's funny too. :cheer:
    • The Lessons of Jedi Manners & Etiquette (Last post by Kitsu Tails)
    • A J.u.s.t Jedi Manual By: The Keeper The Lessons of Jedi Manners & Etiquette Presented by Gathered Force Community A Jedi is a representative of the Force and the Community at large. Our actions determines our worth and ability to be heard. If we cannot respect and show proper manners and etiquette, then, no matter how indepth and worthy your teachings and lessons are to an indavidual the true person missing out is you. Not those that judge you for your actions. As one of the Jedi Behaviors states: Quote: Honor The Jedi Order "When a Jedi behaves badly in public, an observer might think, 'If this Jedi is a representative of the whole Order, then plainly no Jedi is worth respect.' On meeting a second Jedi, who behaves better than the first, that same person might think, 'Does this say that half the Jedi are good, and half bad?' On meeting a third Jedi, who behaves as well as the second, the person thinks, 'Was the first Jedi an exception, then?' In this way, only by the good behavior of several Jedi can the public be certain that the poor behavior of one Jedi was unusual. Thus, it takes many Jedi to undo the mistakes of one." ―Odan-Urr[src] Every action a Jedi made reflected on the Order. Good deeds boosted the Order's reputation, but poor behavior sometimes caused incurable damage. Jedi were taught to remember that each person they met might not have set eyes upon a Jedi before, and that the acts of the particular Jedi that person would influence their perception of the Jedi Order as a whole. Below are several chapters based on Jedi Manners and Etiquette by the beliefs and practices of J.u.s.t Jedi. Thank you for your participation and support *bows* ----- Ch. I - Announce Yourself Guests: No one likes a lurker. That's just weird and just a tiny bit creepy ;) Of course on the internet it is easy to Lurk without the weird and creepy part. But it is still proper etiquette to, at the very least, announce your position. Most online community forums will have an “Introduction” category for just this purpose! Even if you feel as if you are not so good at the whole “Talk about me” thing, you can follow a simple format that will be quite sufficient and will give you the opportunity to learn more about the place you are lurking. Name: Give your Name! Or at least your online ID name ;) Where are you from?: Some of the members come from multiple Jedi (or other) communities. It helps to state what other communities you are a member of so that others from those same locations can relate to your experience and give you a little support. What is your Occupation: Tell a little about yourself! What do you do in the “Really Real World?” Are you a mom/father? Student? Instructor? You don't need to go into full details but just like above, letting people know a little about the things you love and enjoy will help the members of said community relate and support you. Show Interest: Tell why you are there. Is there anything in specific you liked about the community to prompt your introduction? Do you have any questions about the place? It's members? It's process? Now is a great time to ask! Members & Initiates: You are not required to greet new members and say hi. But it sure would be helpful to the Knights and Administration if you did! Remember that the head staff is always very busy and by helping with the small things, such as making a new guest feel welcome, is a great start to behaving and acting like a Jedi. Apprentices: This. Apprentice, should be a requirement. Some communities may not say so or expect it. But part of having proper manners and etiquette is by doing the things not asked of you. You are the doorman, you are the eyes, ears and the representative voice of your Master. S/he cannot always be there to welcome guests and perform the small tasks of social interactions and depends on you to stand out not only for him/her but for yourself and your ability to show your involvement in the community. Knights: The vast majority of the Community should already know how busy you are and respect what you do to keep things running smoothly. But part of the process to that job of your's is to get to know the people you serve. The sooner you can make yourself known through involvement and participation in welcoming members and answering questions is to build a measure of trust and familiarity so that when a problem does arise...the guests and members know it is ok to approach you. If you hide behind the Knights sections of the community and get so involved in your work that none of the members really know who you are besides “That one knight” then you will find yourself in a tense and unfriendly situations later down the road because you didn't take the time to show you cared for “The little people” ----- Author Note: I wasn't sure if I wanted to post it here, or create a "Second" Journal. I decided it might spur some good conversation it is. I will be adding to this with new chapters over the week(s) I hope all enjoy *Bows*
    • Forum Access Changes (Last post by Rickie The Grey)
    • Quote: Feel free to be dissapointed all you would like. Throw a temper tantrum too if you wish. While you do, we will still be here getting things done to improve matters just as we always have. This does not entail dismissing anybody, however those who scream and cry because everything did not happen the way they demanded will only be making things harder on themselves to be thoroughly considered. Going into threads protesting that the knights and council are all dismissive has no constructive basis and only contributes to the already existing conflicts that we are trying to settle. Seems strongly worded, maybe out of frustration? I'm not happy about this anymore now than I was when it first came out but I'm letting go of it. Maybe some/most of us should let this thread rest, take some time for the water to settle down and the air to clear? Peace :)
    • Course Comms (Last post by tzb)
    • Discussion 6 - The Road of Trials now available: PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THE COURSE COMMS THREAD
    • Discussion 6 - The Road of Trials (Last post by tzb)
    • [image] We left our hero... in the belly of the whale, having crossed a threshold into the darkest point since they set out on their adventure. The odds are stacked against them, and there is no easy way out of their predicament. So how will they move forward from here? Our hero has left their ordinary world and entered the world of the adventure. But have they begun to change yet? Thinking of Luke as he enters the Death Star, he is very much the same person he was when he first met Ben - sure, he has his father's lightsaber and he's started to consider the Force, but what has he got to show for this? He has left Tattooine, been captured by the Empire, and now the work of transformation must begin if he is to survive, to "escape", and to become the hero he needs to be. The road of trials is a long, arduous and gruelling stage which will challenge the core beliefs the hero has about themselves, the world they have just entered when setting out on their adventure, and the world they left behind at home. The hero will face repeated challenges and must overcome them, potentially at great cost to themselves or those with them. It is this process of facing and overcoming challenges which enables the transformation and growth our hero needs to reach their ultimate goal. [image] The road of trials may not always be so obviously a road, nor quite so jolly... The "road" may not be a road as such, but it is a sequence of tests and challenges the hero must overcome to reach their eventual goal. The nature of these tests varies considerably depending on the hero's nature, and is likely to incorporate the next few steps along the hero's Journey (meeting the goddess, woman as temptress and atonement with the father), but there are two common elements unique to this stage of the quest: Brother Battle - Frequently the hero must battle someone they considered an ally, perhaps someone in their own quest party who turns against them or is revealed to be a traitor or spy. The hero must overcome this hidden threat and thereby learn a lesson about who they can and can't trust. An example from Star Wars is the battle between Obi-Wan and Vader. Dragon Battle - Dragons are powerfully symbolic creatures in mythology. They represent many things, including the challenges we and others feel are too great to be overcome. The hero is often tasked with confronting such an "unstoppable force", and often overcomes it using their wits rather than outright strength. An example from Lord of the Rings is Gandalf's confrontation with the Balrog. [image] Ultimately the road of trials is a surprising time in the life of our hero, where they are tested and find they have the reserves and ability to overcome the challenges they face. The early triumphs of this stage, immediately after the "darkest hour" of the belly of the whale, provide the hero with the confidence and self-awareness they need in order to achieve their eventual goal. No longer the fish out of water in the world of the adventure, they may find themselves a leader or important figure in the events which unfold. Their actions surprise and sometimes baffle others, but it is thanks to the hero that the road of trials can be passed. So, with this newfound courage and self-esteem, the hero may receive their first glimpse of the world beyond the quest - they may get some idea of the future which lies in store, should the be successful. Often this message arrives with another kind of herald - the goddess. Quote: In the vocabulary of the mystics, this is the second stage of the Way, that of the "purification of the self," when the senses are "cleansed and humbled,1' and the energies and interests "concentrated upon transcendental things"; or in a vocabulary of more modern turn; this is the process of dissolving, transcending, or transmuting the infantile images of our personal past. In our dreams the ageless perils, gargoyles, trials, secret helpers, and instructive figures are nightly still encountered; and in their forms we may see reflected not only the whole picture of our present case, but also the clue to what we must do to be saved. From The Hero with a Thousand Faces Examples Spoiler: * Gilgamesh: Gilgamesh travels through the Land of Night and crosses the Waters of Death on the journey to meet Utnapishtim * The Odyssey: Odysseus faces the trials of Polyphemus, the Circones, the Lotus-Eaters, the Lastrygonians, the sirens, Scylla and Charybdis and the cattle of the sun god * The Enlightenment of Buddha: Buddha is antagonised by "the evil one", including having hurricanes, torrential rains and even flaming rocks to deal with * The Crucifixion of Jesus: Jesus is flogged, mocked by soldiers, clothed in a purple robe, crowned with thorns, beaten and spat on before having to walk to his own execution * Beowulf: Beowulf must not only Grendel, but also his mother and ultimately a dragon * The Theft of Thor's Hammer: Thor must remain "in character" at the brial feast. He almost blows it with his rapacious appetite and red eyes, but Loki's silver tongue saves the day * King Arthur: Arthur founds Camelot, gathers his Knights and battles enemies such as Morgana * The Lord of the Rings: The road to and through Moria, and the breaking of the Fellowship * Star Wars Episode IV: Luke, Han and Chewie must navigate the Death Star to find Leia * The Karate Kid: Mr Miyagi teaches Daniel to fight ("Wax on. Wax off.") * The Lion King: Simba must make a life for himself in the jungle with his new friends Timon and Pumbaa * The Matrix: Neo encounters both the real, and the "hacking" possible in the Matrix, downloads of skills etc * Harry Potter: Again, almost all of Harry's story could be seen as this stage writ large Questions Spoiler: * Life presents us with many trials, and we are sometimes victorious, and sometimes overcome. Think of the two great trials in your life, one in which you were victorious, and one in which you were overcome. Do you feel one allowed you to grow more than the other? Why? * Brother battles are an important but traumatic aspect of this stage of the adventure. Can you think of a time when someone you trusted turned against you? Was your trust misplaced? What did you learn from the experience? * Myth and dream are closely related, in that both reflect the deeply symbolic relationship our imaginations have with our experience of the world. Read this interpretation of dragon dreams. When you think of dragons, how do they make you feel? What do you think they represent? Why do you think so many myths have a dragon as one of the first enemies the hero must overcome? * Fictional Jedi must undergo symbolic "trials" at the end of their training. At TOTJO we don't follow this practice. What trials to TOTJO Jedi face? Think of the benefits for the hero of the road of trials - self-awareness, confidence, early victories. Interesting further reading on the rich archetypal symbolism of the dragon. Next: The Meeting with the Goddess (Available Sunday 26th October)
    • Access Forum Changes (Refined) (Last post by SeventhSL)
    • As I opposed the initial changes I would just like to show my appreciation to the Knights for their efforts with this refinement and to make TOTJO a better place for all of us. I very much understand that you have a difficult task to manage the desires and expectations of so many and I thank you for not hardening your hearts and for listening to the voices of the lower ranks as well as the higher. I sincerely hope that this new solution, or some variation thereof, proves to be successful. I am very hopefull for there is more to a name than their appears. Time tells all things. Also thank you to those higher ranks who take the time to create and discuss topics with those below them. Though it may go unappreciated you act as mentors and guides to beginners like myself. Thank you.
    • American men, American media, and the villificatio... (Last post by carlos.martinez3)
    • you want to draw attention to the wrong...point out? In my life i have seen what kind of things trigger people and this is one. Instead help by educating. teach don't point at show by example... be the right in the wrong world be, the change where its needed, try not to hinder them...who ever it is but in point, yes there is a problem, yes my in laws always...always claim me to be chauvinistic... but my rebuttal isnt to say well your wrong i educate them. I take time to show them there is abetter way there is light in a dark world and i am the light. Now i dont directly say these words to them but i live by example. At the dinner table stand when ever my wife leaves the table...a bit old sckooo i know but the level of respect for my loved one is evident. things like that, yes sir to my son, no sir to him when he asks for things,,,, a better way to do things, the example leaves them speechless at times and they have even grown to respect the methods i teach my family to act and have thanked me at times in their own way.
    • No offense, but... (Last post by Rickie The Grey)
    • Sure. You always have choice. That won't change responsibility if in fact you are responsible. Now stop being so sensitive,
    • My work with the Force (Last post by taidavrikaurvan)
    • Quote: If I were a cynic I would say that you are encouraging people to live in their own delusions instead of reality. BUT I'm not. ;) It was a very good read, a lot of which I agree with, or at least have common threads in my own life philosophy. Did you say Streen was your master? The Streen who writes here on occasion? Also, will you stay and add your voice for awhile? Some of my stuff is a bit out there lol. Thank you for the kind comments. Streen was indeed my master has been for 10 years. I will be here for some time. Listening and learning :)
    • TotJO on Tumblr (Last post by Akkarin)
    • Quote: *does little dance* Hooray! Seriously, I use tumblr as my primary space to blog and is probably more prevalent in my social networking activities than Facebook or Twitter. There are so many of these online things now... Language: Spoiler: [image] :silly:

There are 138 visitors, 4 guests and 34 members online (one is in chat): Br. John, steamboat28, Jestor, Jedi_Roz, ren, Kitsu Tails, Joe, Nakis, Ptolemy, Wescli Wardest, Adhara, Learn_To_Know, Gisteron, Proteus, Luthien, rugadd, Rosalyn J, Rickie The Grey, Llama Su, Archon, zeronycon, elizabeth, Silvermane, tzb, Zenchi, Pyrus Erath, Frost, Cabur Senaar, taidavrikaurvan, Goken, Jeffery Williams, Tarran, Json, Skidder.

Follow Us